Set during the Beatles' months in Hamburg in the early Sixties, the story follows the fifth Beatle, Stuart Sutcliffe, who must choose between his best friend John Lennon, the woman he loves, or the biggest rock group in the world.
While a huge improvement on the dismal TV movie Birth of the Beatles, Iain Softley's account of the Fab Four's Hamburg days is rather like their music of the time: loud, raw and full of energy. It also betrays a lack of experience, leaving too much to enthusiasm and carrying the audience along on euphoria. Focusing primarily on the relationship between John Lennon and Fifth Beatle Stuart Sutcliffe, it descends into tacky melodrama once Stu falls for photographer Astrid Kirchherr, complete with snide tiffs between the spurned Lennon and the woman he considers to be his rival. Ian Hart is solid enough in another of his outings as Lennon (he played the Beatle in The Hours and Times), but Stephen Dorff and Sheryl Lee only occasionally convince as the star-crossed lovers.